Point taken re: the bizarreness of the sentence in question (not that country is the most American of genres, but it's certainly not fringe, even if fringe is part of the aesthetic), but what does it mean to accuse the New York Times of "New York provincialism"? It's a national as well as a local paper, with a perspective that, the further you get from hard news, tilts ... probably towards some living room in the West 70s. If you're really that worked-up about New York's cultural hegemony, perhaps try getting your culture news from a paper that doesn't have "New York" in the name.
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Book!
In March 2017, my first book, "The Perils of 'Privilege'", was published by St. Martin's Press.
For a taste of what it's about, try the "YPIS" tag here.
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(361)
-
▼
July
(42)
- Shades of Napoleon
- "A doctorate in English that probably took you 10 ...
- On a lighter note
- America first
- It takes two
- Goals for the day:
- Natural Nordic beauty indeed: UPDATED
- Keep us out of it
- "On the streets, aside from tourists, one will see...
- The other black hair
- Life choices indeed
- "Now if he can only convince my wife."
- Things that are not my dissertation
- Self-hatred as proud advocacy
- Parc Slope
- The memoirist's lament
- Privilege: denied
- A strategic attempt at losing (male, but also fema...
- Take 3
- Genre coining time: Fauxbivalence, or the apatheti...
- Nobody puts baby artichokes in a corner
- Take 2
- Newfangled whosawhatsis
- "Professor [...] toured shopping centres in Europe...
- The Provinces
- The Palestinian cause vs. the Palestinians' cause
- Ombré manqué
- In search of lost schnitzel
- Glossiest post ever
- In which I gather material for a riveting ex-pat n...
- Your Savage coverage continues UPDATED
- Your daily Francophilic Zionism
- Ever wondered what Heidelberg is like?
- That's personal! UPDATED
- Indolence
- A procrastination directory
- Privilege successfully acknowledged, without exces...
- DTMFA and "other people"
- Anti-Semitism and First World Problems
- Vows, the Gary Shteyngart version
- Pink hair and ice cream
- Where it comes from
-
▼
July
(42)
Labels
- gender studies (490)
- tour d'ivoire (396)
- haute couture (351)
- haute cuisine (193)
- US politics (159)
- personal health (154)
- non-French Jews (142)
- heightened sense of awareness (140)
- young people today (133)
- first-world problems (129)
- vanity (126)
- euphemistic New Jersey (124)
- YPIS (119)
- Old-New Land (115)
- francophilic zionism (114)
- cheapness studies (109)
- I am not French (102)
- another food movement post (94)
- Europinions (92)
- correcting the underrepresentation of New York (80)
- der schrecklichen franzosischen Pudel (79)
- old age (68)
- dirty laundry (67)
- major questions of our age (67)
- race (60)
- I am an intellectual (58)
- lives you could only dream of (58)
- busman's holiday (56)
- fish in a barrel (53)
- persistent motifs (53)
- nineteenth century France (52)
- converting to Flemish (51)
- male beauty (50)
- unpaid internships (48)
- bloggery (45)
- defending the indefensible (44)
- life isn't fair (44)
- Le Reg me manque (40)
- unsupported social commentary (39)
- Jewish babies (38)
- nonsense overanalyzed (37)
- HMYF (35)
- conserva-rants (35)
- vroom vroom (35)
- paging Dan Savage (34)
- non-French Canada (33)
- blather (32)
- cheapness studied then deliberately ignored (31)
- booklined Upper West Side childhoods (30)
- dachshundwatch (29)
- Belles Juives (28)
- rites of passage (26)
- very young people today (26)
- Go Peglegs (24)
- another window of opportunity post (24)
- respect mah authoritah (24)
- wanty (24)
- back to pasta (22)
- fromage (22)
- Grad-Student Anti-Defamation League (21)
- the post-facebook age (21)
- Humanities Anti-Defamation League (20)
- dreams of my dishwasher (20)
- meritocracy mediocrity (20)
- on the intermittent appeal of those subway ads to become an air-conditioner repairman (20)
- rocket science (20)
- unsolicited manifestos (20)
- I am not Japanese (19)
- a long post nobody will read (19)
- contrarian responses to contrarian articles (18)
- too brilliant to bathe (18)
- fiction is better (17)
- on turning my apartment into a Japanese restaurant (17)
- post-YPIS (17)
- woes of gentrification (17)
- it doesn't commute (16)
- the new Brooklyn (16)
- we've come a long way baby (14)
- not-so-young people today (13)
- repeating myself on my blog because I'm too busy to come up with new material and don't want to abandon the blog altogether (13)
- conservative critiques of academia (12)
- fauxbivalence (12)
- further cluttering the internet with Lena Dunham commentary (12)
- love-hate relationships (12)
- WWPD Guides (11)
- holistic (11)
- maybe just maybe gun control (11)
- questions for (both) my readers (11)
- had my Phil (10)
- leaving the house (10)
- susan sontag heidi montag (10)
- Ashkenazi alcohol tolerance (9)
- I am not Californian (9)
- Rufus Wainwrightism (9)
- barely-supported historiographical commentary (8)
- contrarian responses to advice columns (8)
- life imitates art (8)
- pretty privilege (8)
- Don't-Go (7)
- Paris is nice (7)
- builds character (7)
- contrarian responses to fish-in-a-barrel articles (7)
- contrarian responses to non-controversial articles (7)
- gratuitous smug (7)
- rescue culture (7)
- sport (7)
- unsupported psychological commentary (7)
- second after Sartre (6)
- the Allen-Roth two-headed monster (6)
- I am not German (5)
- Orientalism (5)
- act British think Yiddish (5)
- basic life skills (5)
- dreams of my Internet (5)
- genre-coining (5)
- nothing new under the sun (5)
- ombré (5)
- progressive-universalist babies (5)
- Casa Della Bisou (4)
- Gwyneth Paltrow's weekly cigarette (4)
- and that's the last you'll be hearing on this topic (4)
- graphomania (4)
- horribleness (4)
- mansplaining (4)
- perils of overshare (4)
- rainy but worth it (4)
- things that cannot possibly interest anyone else (4)
- utter nonsense (4)
- vigorous defenses of contrarian articles (4)
- weight-think (4)
- French Canada (3)
- I am Liz Lemon (3)
- I am a dirty hippie (3)
- I am actually three (3)
- Invalides (3)
- Isaac Jashevis Singer (3)
- Jews in agriculture (3)
- Undergraduate Anti-Defamation League (3)
- abolish middle school (3)
- an investment piece (3)
- creative types (3)
- eiskaffee (3)
- family values (3)
- hair politics (3)
- high-end stretch pants (3)
- hopeless attempts at photographing household objects (3)
- in which I translate from the Style section (3)
- kaas (3)
- kale (3)
- the contemporary relevance of 1970s sitcoms (3)
- unsupported legislative commentary (3)
- unsupported political commentary (3)
- unsupported style commentary (3)
- writing about writing (3)
- British television overanalyzed (2)
- I am an art ignoramous (2)
- I am an art ignoramus (2)
- Miss Fine (2)
- Quinn and the Fashion Club (2)
- art imitates life (2)
- avoiding the news cycle (2)
- bloggery as self-life-coaching (2)
- converting to Flemish maybe some other time (2)
- entitled much? (2)
- fast fashion (2)
- feelings (2)
- goils were goils and men were men (2)
- guilt (2)
- having thoughts on the major legal and political stories of the day but only sharing thoughts about fashion (2)
- interior decorating (2)
- meh (2)
- non-Canadian North America (2)
- not quite first world problems (2)
- on her former employment at a bridal shop in Flushing Queens (2)
- pickitarianism (2)
- provincial complaints (2)
- self-improvement (2)
- unsupported neurological commentary (2)
- utter genius (2)
- your questions answered (2)
- Festivus (1)
- French-teacher anti-defamation league (1)
- Greater Philadelphia (1)
- I am not a medievalist (1)
- I am not a wine connoisseur (1)
- Sandy-whine (1)
- Simon Doonan and the tongue-in-cheek defense (1)
- The Moment (1)
- a post on which I expect no comments (1)
- autobiographical projection (1)
- because it's there (1)
- biology 101 (1)
- bonapartism (1)
- buried ledes (1)
- busman's holiday avoided (1)
- casualwear sexism (1)
- contrarian cheapness advice (1)
- contrarian responses to legislation (1)
- contrarian responses to perfectly lovely urban developments (1)
- contrarianism (1)
- early-twentieth-century France (1)
- embarrassing confessions (1)
- exercises in futility (1)
- fashion and feminism (1)
- first-world French-major-specific problems (1)
- friendship (1)
- great escapes (1)
- hamster-wheel workouts (1)
- hareglayim shelee (1)
- how is there not already a Natalie Portman tag (1)
- imaginary French boyfriends (1)
- in which God walks out of the men's room (1)
- matzo brei (1)
- mini-bailouts (1)
- miscellaneous seafood in a barrel (1)
- neurosis (1)
- not sarcastic I swear (1)
- on the foolishness of Googling one's own name or the title of something one has written (1)
- overanalyzing so-last-season cultural phenomena (1)
- oxymorons (1)
- pasta anti-defamation league (1)
- placeholders (1)
- pot meets kettle (1)
- psychology of sub-dollar expenditures (1)
- quasi-offensive reappropriation (1)
- rampant materialism (1)
- renewed germophobia (1)
- round-ups (1)
- shameless attempts to provoke a dwindling libertarian readership (1)
- shortness overanalyzed (1)
- something is fishy (1)
- terroir (1)
- the final word (1)
- there oughta be a law (1)
- unsupported climate-science commentary (1)
- unsupported philosophical commentary (1)
- warm welcomes (1)
- you don't care (1)
7 comments:
I have a longstanding beef with the way the NYT reports news outside the coasts, but I don't think it's "provincial" to suggest that a genre might have ambassadors to the mainstream. I like country music and romance novels, both of which are enormously popular in the U.S., but are nonetheless genres, and moreover ones with limited intellectual prestige. It's no more provincial to note country's genre nature than to note that of science-fiction.
Also, I suspect that if Shelton hadn't been coming from one of the more politically and culturally conservative genres, he would've been more careful than to tweet about how "any man who tries touching my behind is gonna be a beaten, bleeding, heaving kind of guy."
PG,
"I have a longstanding beef with the way the NYT reports news outside the coasts"
Does it report accurately (cultural news, that is) re: anywhere outside of Manhattan and gentrified Brooklyn? Or is that what you mean by "coasts"?
I suppose I don't see why there'd be "beef" here, given that the paper, when not covering hard news, is provincial, and why not? Isn't that better than a NY-based, NY-named paper claiming to be the highest authority on all of America, region by region? I'd think a stronger case could be made that only certain NYers' lives are covered in those cultural sections, and they're people whose power and influence arguably stems primarily from their having been written about in the NYT.
Outside of NY, the paper is marketed as a national newspaper. I don't think it is asking too much to expect it to live up to the image the paper itself tries to project. Provincialism may not be the correct word, but it is not uncommon to encounter New Yorkers who know very little about the culture or geography of the rest of the country. The NY Times is obviously a very good newspaper, but coverage of the Midwest and South is sometimes inaccurate and condescending.
Anon,
The paper is national, but with a local specificity, much like, say, the equivalents from L.A. or D.C. It's not marketed as entirely national, or they'd have to do something about the title, they'd have to chuck the "New York" news section from the sidebar, etc., before even beginning to integrate Kansas into the Style section.
What I find ridiculous is the notion that it's anything worse than provincialism for New Yorkers to be, well, provincial. You complain that "it is not uncommon to encounter New Yorkers who know very little about the culture or geography of the rest of the country." How much do Midwesterners know about the South or Northeast? How much do Southerners know about the Midwest or Northeast? Everyone's from somewhere, and unless you happened to move around a lot as a kid, or have for some other reason undertaken to educate yourself about All Of America, you probably do know more about where you're from than elsewhere.
That in no way excuses errors in reporting, if that's what you mean by "coverage," nor does it excuse being "condescending," and I'll take your word for it on both counts, but examples are always useful, if anyone's to be convinced of this who didn't already think this of the paper instinctively.
Point is, you're not going to get the best - which includes most nuanced - local/culture/lifestyle news about any place but NY from the NYT. If that bothers you, why are you letting a New York paper provide you with your cultural news? Just because of its fine front-page coverage of hard news?
My complaint about the NYT's coverage of flyover country is actually more with their hard news coverage of Texas (although just now discovering Mexican martinis? evidently my efforts to introduce these to New Yorkers my first year of law school took a long time to germinate). Anonymous's remark about condescending and sometimes-inaccurate hits the mark. I started reading the NYT when their going online coincided with my family's getting Ye Olde Prodigy internet service in 1996, and I remember being troubled enough by their "of course all these small town Southerners are racists" coverage of the James King case (black man dragged to death by some white guys in a pickup; his kids went to high school with my little sister and me) that I alluded to it years later in my law school admission essay.
For a more recent example, there's my own perspective on the NYT article on a gang-rape in Cleveland, TX that drew a lot of flack from the left because they claimed the Times was blaming the assault victim -- when in fact, they were accurately reporting what some of the more ignorant and misogynistic (including misogynistic women) in town were saying. At no point in the article did the Times say these were their own views or a statement of objective reality.
However, I'm skeptical that the Times would be doing this sort of "community reaction reporting" in its own neighborhoods. I'm sure there were people saying stupid stuff in the streets of NYC wrt the woman assaulted by an NYPD officer while she was drunk and had initially invited him into her apartment. (I'm sure of it because people were definitely saying stupid victim-blaming stuff online.) When trying to represent "what New Yorkers are saying," the Times doesn't seem to look for and print the most ignorant quotes possible.
PG,
Examples, thanks! (Not being sarcastic, this is giving me a better sense.)
"When trying to represent 'what New Yorkers are saying,' the Times doesn't seem to look for and print the most ignorant quotes possible."
I'm not so sure about that. There's the "styles style" MSI writes about, wherein people from demographics not remotely small-town or Southern (aka rich-to-super-rich NYers) are written about in a way that's on one level flattering, but on another, between the lines yet somehow incredibly obvious way, cruelest (if deserved) mockery. I'm not sure how much this extends beyond "lifestyle" articles, but I wouldn't be that surprised if it did.
Post a Comment